Home
Learn More About CoH
Visit CoH Library
Explore CoH Communities
Contribute to CoH Blog
Get Involved

Archive for April, 2009

The real work begins

Wednesday, April 29th, 2009

In his recent blog post, Robert Wood Johnson Foundation’s Dr. James Marks writes: “What are the barriers to better health…and where does health really start? Only when we answer these questions honestly and see health in this broader context, will we begin the real work…”

 

We couldn’t agree more — and this “real work” must be an ongoing and participative process, like peeling back a never-ending and infinitely complex onion to see what’s inside.

 

The RWJF Commission to Build a Healthier America’s recommendations report is a wonderful milepost, filled with evidence and stories of hope. Also wonderful is an open question (overheard as a candid aside between Commissioners at one of RWJF’s public hearings): Is anyone even listening? And if not, we might ask, Why is this so? Questions like these invite a deeper inquiry that must unfold if we are to begin the real work of profound and sustainable change.

As we examine the societal, structural and contextual conditions that lead to poor health, we must also consider what values — what ways of thinking and acting and being — led to these conditions in the first place. As Churchill said, “We shape our buildings, then our buildings shape us.”

The good news is that coming together to consider questions that matter is intrinsically healthy. In coming together we re-connect with what is most important. We create inclusive environments where every voice can be heard. And we begin to see that the exterior conditions in which we live and work are manifestations of our collective interior conditions, and that means we can change them together.

 

The “real work” is interior work. And this work is always now.

Joy and sorrow

Sunday, April 26th, 2009

The e-mail came early this morning, a friend’s update on the difficult family situation he shared two weeks ago that had become a raging storm: pain, fear, loss. And also a time of deep joy; a family coming together over great distances, holding each other and being held.

We are, as Hawthorne writes, beings capable of eternal joy or sorrow, confided to each other’s care. There’s a fantastical story about this in the current issue of The New Yorker, and many more right here among us.

“Allowing” voice and the function of history

Sunday, April 19th, 2009

During a call with a brilliant public official in the Twin Cities of western Michigan, one of our pilots sites, we discussed the importance of allowing each participant in our work to have his or her voice, to allow each to make his or her own meaning. Sounds sensible and compassionate on the face.

Then the danger in such a view begins to take shape. To wit: ”allowing” the other to make his own meaning establishes a power structure. Oppressor and oppressed. How do we enter the other’s world without the subtle kinds of violence that overwhelm voice so thoroughly we are compelled to “allow” (as in grant permission) them to exercise that voice? And what am I to do when the other tells me with his “authentic” voice that he opposes me? 

Then there’s the function of history. While the oppressor is unlikely to cede all power — in fact, in many cases the full reach of this power is unknown if not unwanted – it’s also likely the oppressed serves a historically critical role as he attempts through the frame of granted permission to make his own meaning and speak with his own voice. Eventually these voices, allowed their dissent, undermine the authority of the oppressor.

It’s as if each individual has an agenda and directs all his efforts to realizing that agenda. It’s all we can see, and we defend all our actions as necessary for the mission. Meanwhile history operates on a different plane. If this were not the case, Martin Luther King, Jr, would have realized his agenda in his too-short lifetime. The changes he dreamed are coming; his was but one voice in the long march of history.

A little more love

Thursday, April 16th, 2009

At dinner in NYC Monday night, one of us said, “There are different kinds of love,” and then in very open, honest terms described these over a particular shared experience that was in fact experienced in many different ways.

And then this posting arrived, as though the conversation wanted to continue. She asks: What are these many forms, these things each one of us know about love, “in all its surrealistic avatars”? When does love honor the “unique individuality of the other”? When does it move us “from the narrow confines of our ego into the broader, more generous realm of relationship”?

There is of course a connection here to health, as Dr. Dean Ornish (among so many others) makes: “Love and intimacy are the root of what makes us sick and what makes us well, what causes sadness and what brings happiness, what makes us suffer and what leads to healing. Our survival depends on the healing power of love, intimacy, and relationships.”

It’s a conversation worth continuing.

Real Piracy

Wednesday, April 15th, 2009

Seems like the pirates off the coast of Africa have highjacked more than freighters and a sea captain or two. They’ve also taken our media hostage. Lifeboats and Navy Seals and Somali pirates and high-seas heroism have nudged an impending cataclysm out of the media spotlight. Wouldn’t it be terrific if we could resume the life we seem entitled to? I for one would love to be able to tell my college-sophomore daughter to go ahead and accept all the credit card offers that will soon fill her mailbox. That she really deserves a summer of borrowed leisure; after all, she’s earned it. Well, even if she hasn’t earned it I don’t want her to have to make any hard choices. That could make her feel very much out of step with the rest of the culture. It might actually mean she would have to figure out what and who she really is, rather than letting the fickle winds of commerce make those calls for her. It’s just so much easier to avoid the hard realities.

All connected

Monday, April 6th, 2009

Last night’s 60 Minutes was a powerful reminder of the interconnectedness of it all: “It’s the next thing in the recession: communities cutting back on services like schools or cops or public hospitals because tax revenues have fallen with the economy.”

 

In this story, it’s Las Vegas cancer patients who can no longer receive life-giving therapies from University Medical Center (UMC), a safety net for two million people that, due to state budget cuts, closed its outpatient clinic for chemotherapy.

  

As UMC CEO Kathy Silver explains, “Obviously, our gaming and tourism is tanking. The construction industry has been decimated. And all of those things cause big, gaping holes in the state budget. The hardest-hit area for us was the Medicaid budget.” While Las Vegas is experiencing its biggest downturn ever, the crisis is being felt by all cities, says Silver. “I think this is happening, to some degree, to probably every public hospital across the country. I think it’s happening to us to a greater degree because…we’re sort of the epicenter of what’s happening. We’re a demonstration project…of all the things that can go wrong at once.”

 

I remember reading a year ago about cuts to a small but vital resource in Portland, Maine, which helped that city’s growing number of Somali immigrants learn essentials like how to read a bus schedule and how to cook using an indoor gas stove, as well as more commonly considered guidance on local education, health and job programs. It was likely a $15K save to the budget, but the impact of helping new citizens regain a sense of belonging and control was invaluable (and, now missing, is likely showing up in all sorts of ways the city and its people are paying for many times over).

 

Back in Las Vegas, Dr. Nick Spiritos, who worked at UMC’s now-closed women’s clinic, continues to provide treatment to displaced cancer patients through his own upgraded facility, which he financed. Patients pay only if (and what) they can afford to; Dr. Spiritos and his partners cover the rest.

 

As the Nevada state legislature considers a proposal that would cut millions more from the UMC budget, public comments on the 60 Minutes site voice ideas, frustration, anger, and offers of support:

 

“One way many people can help out these patients is by simply coming back to Las Vegas (so that) more revenue from casinos is pumped back into our state budget.” … “Can you tell me how I can help the woman who does not have any insurance?” … “If we all encouraged everyone we know to send $1.00 to Dr. Spiritos foundation, imagine the help that could be done.” … “Considering its wealth, Nevada is already one of the worst states for funding education, mental health, and drug treatment. Tourists from around the world should consider boycotting Las Vegas and the casinos here until this city and state helps its people.” … “How do I get a hold of Roy Scales (profiled in the story)? He helped (me) through some of the most difficult days of my life…When he was in Pittsburgh about 14 years ago we were both down on our luck.”

There is something we can do, not just to ameliorate the impact of the current crisis but also to avoid another one. Remember that what we’re seeing and what we’re not seeing – all of it and all of us – we’re all connected. And, be there for each other.

RWJF Commission Releases Recommendations

Wednesday, April 1st, 2009

On April 2, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Commission to Build a Healthier America releases 10 recommendations for dramatic improvements in the health of all Americans. The recommendations are rooted in a twin philosophy: good health requires each of us to make healthy choices and society to help remove the obstacles preventing too many Americans from making healthy decisions.

 

Commissioners release their report 9:30am-11:30am (Eastern) in Washington, DC, and will also host a live Twitter chat from the event (follow RWJFCommission or add to the conversation by using the event hashtag, #cbha).

 

CIGNA, which launched Communities of Health (CoH) last year, applauded the Commission’s recommendations, and called on all leaders to join in a movement to improve community conditions that influence health. 

 

The CoH team will be at the event and we look forward to working together with all toward real, sustainable change.